Musicians Are Getting the Blues
show comments
  • Kenny

    Two points, Mr. Mead.

    First, “the rapid increase in musical virtuosity over the past generation, to the point where bygone masters would have trouble simply gaining acceptance to Julliard today.”

    No mystery here. In the past, only a minuscule percent of the population has the resources to try its hand at music. But now with all our influence, millions and millions more have joined the mix.

    Elementary statistics is so clear on this matter that even a public school graduate should be able to understand that the ‘virtuosity’ standards of the past are a joke today.

    Second, the fact that ‘talented’ musicians can’t get jobs is an indication that they are a dime a dozen relative to the demand for their services.

    As reality is showing, these classical musicians are not nearly as special as they have thought themsleves to be.

  • bentunder

    The success of a field as esoteric as classical music is dependent on a class of people wealthy enough to have the leisure and training to appreciate it.

    Most of us get some ‘training’ through exposure in popular media, enough to recognize and be moved by highlights. Real appreciation for a full length work by Bach, Beethoven, Wagner, Mahler, etc takes a commitment of time (hours and years) that the vast majority of us will never have the luxury to make.

    I have a performance degree from a music conservatory and don’t take the time for works of any length anymore. How could expect anyone else to?

    If you want to be a classical musician, become independently wealthy first. That way, you can do what you want, and you’ll be able to relate to your audience.

  • Jim.

    You mention Russia’s musical tradition — musicians in this country would do well to remember it.

    Lesson one: There’s no shame in a day job.

    Nor will a day job prevent you from writing or performing some of the most beautiful music ever written.

    Rimsky-Korsakov was a naval officer. Borodin was a talented biochemist. Cesar Cui was a military engineer. Mussorgsky was a lousy drunk, and that never did him any good.

    Lesson two: Just make the music.

    Music can never be a vocation for more than a very, very few. It should be an avocation for far more than it is.

    From 7-13 August 2000, audiences in Hong Kong welcomed the Moscow Philharmonic orchestra. The performances received very good reviews. But on the nitpicky side, the erstwhile satisfied concertgoers complained when they found out the performers were not in fact the Moscow Philharmonic.

    http://www.museumofhoaxes.com/philharmonic.html

    Just make the music. And if you need bread, bake it for yourself.

  • Corlyss

    I remember the same complaint uttered in 1978. Music schools and departments were graduating tens of thousands of students into an economy that could accommodate only a few thousand. The speaker declared that for every vacancy in an orchestra there were 100 applicants, all of whom were very good. Since then, many regional orchestras popped up. And not coincidentally, the number of music school grads expanded too. What is really missing is an Esterhazy family, i.e., a wealthy patron who can afford the cost of maintaining an orchestra and a composer. Ain’t coming back. Those days are gone forever.

  • Marion Kee

    As a near-lifelong musician, in my senior year of high school I had a choice to plan to pursue a professional music career or to leave music as an avocation and focus my college years on math, languages and history–important areas where my available prior education had been lacking.

    While I was pondering my options, one of my longtime friends, a promising pianist (and vocalist as well) was in a car accident where the steering wheel shattered in her hands. Her tendons and some bones in both hands had to be reconstructed. After studying piano since kindergarten, sometimes to the exclusion of other academic areas, she would never be able to have a performance career.

    My gut made the choice when I heard about her situation. I focused on straight academic areas in college rather than in fine arts. When opportunity presented, I also went on pursuing my semiprofessional music career on the side.

    That was all more than 30 years ago. I’m still making music on the side. I’m not picky about getting paid; I don’t have to be. I am picky about playing with people I can learn from, and with. My day job for a long time was a career in computer science, but I’ve done a lot of things to pay the bills. Day jobs are bread and butter. Music is jam.

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2017 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.