The President's Speech
Arab Press Takes Obama’s Speech With a Grain (or Five) of Salt
show comments
  • B-Sabre

    More than few grains…

    • Government Drone

      “Top Flake”, indeed.

  • FriendlyGoat

    The only thing these papers should be opining on is whether they and their nations agree with Obama (in yesterday’s speech) that “ISIL is not Islamic”. Little else matters.

    The Arab countries either can or cannot supervise soldiers who will fight the ISIL brand of Islam. They either do or do not believe their own governments are at risk of being destabilized by this movement. They either do or do not wish to run the risk of appearing to be allied with the USA.

    They either stand up for a sensible Islam —-OR—-they capitulate to the self-proclaimed caliphate. Most everything else is hot air.

    • ShadrachSmith

      Islam is what it is. And the Koran says what it says. You can’t have ‘sensible’ Islam. You either have Islam or you don’t.

      • FriendlyGoat

        Well, I actually agree with you that the whole of Islam is a colossal fib and an evil force.

        But, most of the billion or so adherents haven’t beheaded or stoned anyone lately and have no intention of doing so. The question is whether THEY will recapture Islam or whether they will be brought under subjection by the others. This is truly an open question, and the only one that’s going to matter much.

        Islamic citizens (anywhere) either can or cannot control the “wildfire” elements of their own faith. They either will or will not confront self-proclaimed authoritarian clerics for the sake of maintaining a semblance of modernity in their lands.

        When we speak of coalitions, who are we going to find?

        • ShadrachSmith

          That there are many muslims, does not make anything easier. The problem is what it is.

          • FriendlyGoat

            True, the fact that so many people have been fooled by Islam IS THE PROBLEM with Islam. If there were not so many of them, the whole thing could be much more easily consigned to an ash-heap with other falsehoods.

            But a billion (or so) there are. Either they want to live modern lives enough to confront their fringes, or they don’t.

            Westerners cannot do this for them. They have to muster up the sense and courage themselves—-or, they have to get local dictators again (hopefully better than their last ones). Egypt appears to be going this route with Sisi, for instance. I recently read he has a Minister of Religion in the government there who has banished thousands of the crazier clerics from preaching in the mosques of Egypt—-a form of heavy-handedness that may sound odd to us, yet be legitimately REQUIRED for the immense problems they face.

      • Thirdsyphon

        That’s like saying the Bible supports only one version of Christianity, and you can either “have” it or not. The text doesn’t change; but it can be and has been used to support a vast array of different interpretations that cover the waterfront from Pope Francis to David Koresh. ISIS isn’t the “real” Islam any more than Joseph Kony’s Lord’s Resistance Army is the “real” Christianity.

        • ShadrachSmith

          You are over your head. My point is completely valid. The Koran is accepted as the literal, unchangeable, direct word of God. Christianity used to do that, but hasn’t in several hundred years. We mostly accept that our text is fallible. Suggesting that the Koran is fallible will get you hung in Saudi Arabia. In fact sharia law requires it. A glaring example of what is wrong with Islam is that thinking bad thoughts about the Koran is punishable by death. Freedom of thought…punishable by death…see the political problem?

          • Thirdsyphon

            Christians no longer think that the Bible is the literal word of God? That’s news to me, and I suspect that this information will likewise come as a shock to the 45% or so of Americans who keep telling pollsters that they believe the Earth and all the species that inhabit it, including us, were created by God in their current form around 10,000 years ago.

            http://www.gallup.com/poll/155003/hold-creationist-view-human-origins.aspx

            And yet, notwithstanding the truly depressing number of crimes for which the Biblical prescription is death, Those 45% of Americans are conspicuously not out in the streets burning witches, stoning adulterers, and ripping out blasphemers’ tongues.

            My point? Simply this: that believing (or claiming to believe) in the literal truth of a bloodthirsty-sounding religious text is not, of itself, a guarantee of violence. History proves that there’s nothing in the “source code” of either Christianity or Islam that mandates either violence or peace.

          • ShadrachSmith

            You share a flaw with climate scientists, the facts over the last couple decades seem to disprove your theory.

          • Thirdsyphon

            And you share a flaw with climate skeptics: you’re intentionally choosing your data to fit your theory, instead of the other way around.

  • Arkeygeezer

    Looks to me like the American public, our allies, and our enemies agree that the U.S. should stay out of Syria, and limit its air support to only those ground troops willing to fight ISIS.

    • Thirdsyphon

      That’s. . .actually not a terrible plan. Drawing a “bright line” between Iraq and Syria would keep America’s role in the conflict at least somewhat contained, and would mollify Putin and Assad. . . which is ironic, because it would also create a strong incentive for ISIS to pull their people and resources back into Syria, which will make them a much bigger headache for Putin and Assad.

      Conversely, if the US engages in airstrikes on both sides of the Iraq/Syria border right out of the gate, there’s no incentive for ISIS to withdraw back into Syria since they’ll be facing U.S. forces either way.

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2017 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.