Saving Face/Climbing Down
US Expels Accused Diplomat, Settles Dispute with India
show comments
  • Kevin

    Why did she not have diplomatic immunity in the first place? The police/prosecutor seemed particularly clueless, if not caught up in some macho need to exercise their own power and show how important they were. ow did they think this was going to end? Why strip search her instead of holding on to get while they contacted the State Department?
    What she did was clearly at odds with American law and custom, but strip searching foreign diplomats is crazy, just expel her quietly. She would have gone home in disgrace rather than turned into a martyr.

    • TheCynical1

      These are good questions, which, to my knowledge, are not being addressed by the American commentariat.

      I wonder if the Justice Department even checked at all with the State Department beforehand. If Justice did check, why didn’t State take charge promptly and proceed more discreetly. Given the potential consequences for U.S. diplomacy, how senior were those in the loop — did this go up to Holder and Kerry. And ultimately, what does this say about the day-to-day competence of Justice and State — and more generally, this Administration — in light of many other larger questions about them.

      One reason I don’t think too much of the mainstream media (left or right) is because, all too often, they seem to overlook basic questions that serious journalists would presumably think of.

      • Andrew Allison

        If you can identify a “serious journalist”, please do so. Meanwhile, what hasn’t been addressed is the Gestapo, er police, practice of strip searching ANYBODY arrested for civil, rather than criminal offenses. Seems to me a clear civil rights violation.

  • Anthony

    Laws, laws, laws, (what are we to make of them) to whom are they to be applied and by whom are they to be efficaciously exercised: Devyani Khobragade indicted and given diplomatic immunity to leave for India; equally status U.S. diplomat to be ousted from American Embassy in New Delhi. Welcome to high level diplomatic strategic U.S./Indian vital relations. By the way, nanny Sangeeta Richard, catalyst for episode, becomes invisible human in these international, cross cultural, and jurisprudential contretemps – settled at whose expense (climbing down/saving face).

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2017 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites.