Let the Nurse Practitioners Work
show comments
  • Maynerd

    Unfortunately, the details of the study, beyond the abstract, are behind the “Health Affairs” journal fire wall.

    I am a specialist MD and not a primary care physician. Count me as skeptical that large savings exist using mid-levels (NP’s and PA’s) as surrogate primary care physicians. My specialist colleagues all bemoan the unnecessary imaging, lab work, and specialty consultation generated by the relatively insecure and inexperienced mid-levels. It would be interesting to add up the total global cost to the health care system of a mid level vis a vis an MD.

    The premise that a few years of training is equivalent to 4 years of uber intense medical school and three additional years of residency is comical.

    For all of who advocate this wonderful frugal approach please walk the walk. Discard your child’s pediatrician and your internist and embrace the nurse practitioner. I’m confident you will enjoy the fruits of our brave new and improved health care system.

    • Andrew Allison

      Where to begin? With your blatant self-interest? Or with your ridiculous assertion that “the unnecessary imaging, lab work, and specialty consultation” is not generated
      by CYA MDs?

      The fact is that for most primary care (with which you acknowledge you are unfamiliar), NP’s and PA’s are at least as well qualified as MDs. As a recipient, rather than a provider, of healthcare, it’s my impression that the so-called “mid-level” practitioners are more, rather than less, likely to recognize when they need to make a referral.

      • Maynerd

        You seem a bit hostile. But that’s OK. As I stated, go ahead and enjoy the new system.

        Regarding my “blatant self interest”, mid levels increase my work and therefore my income. And that is my point. Mid levels drive up the cost of health care by their lack of training and experience. Not to mention the increased liability costs they generate.

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2017 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.