Voters in Cash-Strapped Michigan Say “It Takes a Village”
show comments
  • Andrew Knutson

    Consolidation leads to corruption. Check out Duval and Dade counties in Florida.
    Promised efficiencies disappear and accountability fades away.

  • Jacksonian Libertarian

    “The Government Monopoly can never be the efficient organ that Leftists desire, because it suffers from the same problem all Monopolies suffer from; the lack of feedback from competition that forces continuous improvements in Quality, Service, and Price, in the Capitalist System.” Jacksonian Libertarian

    There is a village outside Atlanta that contracts out all of its services, and has only 2 employees (Manager, and a Lawyer). It forces businesses to compete to provide the services the village requires, and because of this the Quality, Service, and Price are all massively better than the other towns around Atlanta. If this Michigan village does the same, I would expect similar results.

  • John Burke

    I know nothing about these Michigan municipalities, but I am a longtime resident of Westchester County, NY, which has a crazy quilt of townships, villages within the towns or stretching across town borders, and school districts that overlap all the rest. Plus, there is a county-level government with significant responsibilities. Every so often, some “good government” types complain about this disorderly system, catalog supposed redundancies, and claim that “reform” would produce all manner of efficiencies and cost savings, usually by consolidations and concentrating more power at the county level.

    But this is all baloney. The current system may seem messy, but it keeps local government really local. In villages of 10,000 or 15,000, municipal officials are constantly on the hot seat. Waste, corruption, mismanagement, etc. are impossible to hide and harder to justify to citizens who gladly show up at board meetings to complain and bottonhole elected leaders who are otherwise mere neighbors. School boards are even more kept on a short leash by active parents.

    Bigger is rarely better where government is concerned.

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2017 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites.