India’s Gendercide Doesn’t Stop At Birth
show comments
  • Mrs. Davis

    I have to agree that the tone here seems to be coarsening and the analysis weakening. Things are really better for females in Pakistan? Are you including Baluchistan and the NWFA? What evidence is there to support this statement, particularly in light of this.

    And why isn’t this am Indian problem for the Indians to deal with? We certainly didn’t need the British involved in the resolution of our slavery problem. Publicize and condemn it, but it is an Indian problem for the Indians to deal with. We should be neither the world’s policeman nor it’s nanny. What arrogance to see it otherwise.

  • Kris

    Sir Charles Napier, anyone?

  • Jim.

    I think the Christianization of India should be actively encouraged.

    It cured infanticide in the Roman Empire, it would likely do the same in India.

  • Anthony

    As Mrs. Davis suggests: an entire assembly of voices ought to denounce gender/female abuse (FGM and Gendercide). There can be no doubt that the fate of women/girls around the world impacts future population dynamics.

  • Riki Tiki Tavi

    I agree with Mrs. Davis. This post is unbalanced. It says nothing about all the things that the government and civic society have done to counter this issue. Nor does it acknowledge that some analysts believe that matters may actually be improving. See article from The Economist for an alternative take.

  • dearieme

    Send in the drones.

  • ErisGuy

    Aborting unwanted clumps of fetal cells is called “choice,” not “gendercide.”

    I think you should respect and tolerate the differences of other, unique, superior, non-Western cultures. Let the Indians decide how to run India. Give no voice to American academics and ideologues, whose record in “helping” America is almost wholly negative.

  • Tom Richards

    The issue is the killing of millions of individuals, not that such killing is motivated by the sex of those individuals.

    For this reason, it is important to distinguish between abortion and willful post-natal neglect. The latter is unquestionably heinous; the status of the former hinges on an unresolved (and potentially irresoluble) question of fact. We do not know whether foetuses have the characteristics we consider important for moral personhood. We’re not even terribly clear on what characteristics those might be. The evidence suggests, but does not guarantee, that by most reasonable definitions in the earlier stages of gestation at least they do not. On each side of the argument we must weigh the degree of harm if we are wrong against the likelihood that we are right. On balance, I believe the state of the evidence favours permitting abortion within relatively strict term limits. Future advances in our understanding could tip that balance either way – hypothetically as far as an outright ban in all cases where the life of the mother is not seriously threatened to legalised killing of young children after birth (though I do not think either of these radical extremes is likely to be either suggested by the evidence or tolerated by society).

  • Jbird

    How are the Indian and Chinese governments so stupid that they don’t recognize this is going to be a huge problem in 20 years or less.

  • Eurydice

    @Tom – I’m sorry, but that’s just a lot of blahdy, blah, blah. It makes no difference whether the foetus has the characteristics for moral personhood – what matters is that the foetus is being aborted because it will grow to be a female. That’s the definition of “motivated by the sex of those individuals.”

  • Kris

    [email protected]: So what if I decide to refrain from sex henceforth because my Guru has told me that my next child will be female?

  • justaguy

    Jim @ #3 says:
    I think the Christianization of India should be actively encouraged.

    It cured infanticide in the Roman Empire, it would likely do the same in India.

    Really? Infantacide and killing of daughters continued in Rome until their conquest by the more fertile tribes of barbarians. see Spengler or numerous other historians. The lack of will to continue population destroyed Greece and then Rome in ancient times and seems to be killing many a country today. The brief European/Christian experience where population actually grew seems to be returning to mean.

  • Beginning of December, a program aired on ABC 20/20 about India’s deadly secret. It was about 40 million girls who have vanished. All aborted before they could take their first breath. Their crime was that they were girls. As you know the gender ratios is India are terribly skewed about 914 girls per 1,000 boys. In Punjab it is about 833 girls per1,000 boys. Unfortunately this happens amongst the privileged and the educated also. The only woman who has brought cases against her in-laws and husband is Dr Mitu Khurana. Please watch her story and sign her petition for justice. Please give those 40 million girls silenced forever, a voice. Please forward this to as many friends as possible.

    After you sign the petition, there will be a request from the site for a donation. This donation is totally discretionary and does not in any way or form affect or benefit Dr Mitu Khurana. All she is asking for is your support (signing this petition) so that pressure can be put on the Indian authorities that the whole world is watching them in total disbelief as they make a young mother run around in vain for four years in search of justice

  • Eurydice

    @Kris #11 – I’m not sure why you’re dragging a guru into this. My response was with regard to logic, not spirituality. If you decide never to have sex because you don’t want to give birth to a girl, then your decision is based on gender.

  • Kris

    [email protected]: Yes, of course my decision is based on gender. Does that mean I am engaging in a moral wrong? Are you claiming that this is the problem, as opposed to abortion itself? (I am trying to understand your dismissive response to Tom.)

  • Please visit the website for the Gendercide Awareness Project. It is We are DOING something about this! Please send us baby booties! You’ll see what I mean.

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2017 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites.