mead berger shevtsova garfinkle michta grygiel blankenhorn bayles
Showdown in Brazil
Lula Gets Convicted

Brazil’s former President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva has been convicted for corruption and sentenced to prison for nine and a half years. The Financial Times notes that markets are loving the news:

While the populist leader remains free pending appeal, the ruling threatens to eliminate him from the running for presidential elections next year, an outcome that pleased markets.

The country’s benchmark Bovespa stock index rose 1.6 per cent on the news, while the Brazilian real extended its earlier gains to trade 1.4 per cent higher at R$3.2079 per dollar — a two-month high.

“You are removing a candidate who definitely the market did not want to see there,” said Alberto Bernal, chief emerging markets and global strategist at XP Securities in Miami.

Many on the Left will believe that the court is acting politically. Over the last few years it has become clear that almost every member of the country’s political establishment is corrupt, Left, Right and Center. Paradoxically that can lead voters to discount corruption allegations: If they are all crooks, why not pick the crooks on “your” side?

Lula remains the most popular politician in a divided country. The establishment fears, probably with good reason, that a new Lula administration would be even more statist and corrupt than before. But if much of the population believes that he is being unfairly punished for sins that all the other politicians commit, jailing Lula or banning him from the next election could bring on a crisis. It is not clear how long the fragile consensus behind Brazil’s legal and political institutions will last under these unprecedented circumstances.

Brazil, with roughly half the population and half the GDP of all of Latin America, is floundering badly. Stability, prosperity and democracy in Brazil are more important than ever as Venezuela edges toward civil conflict. This story is worth following.

Features Icon
show comments
  • Fat_Man

    When will the US learn that the stability and welfare of the countries in our own neighborhood is the most important issue in our foreign policy.

  • Pait

    That’s Brazil showing America the way.

    • Dale Fayda

      I agree. Obama has a lot of corruption to answer for. And there is a whole wing of a Federal prison waiting for the entire Clinton crime family.

  • Josephbleau

    It’s still a better result than you will see in Mexico or Argentina. Why not appreciate the small effort. I don’t take work in SA anymore (I do in southern North America though, I know the territory better.)

  • QET

    What is TAI’s position on Lula: is he “unfit”? That appears to be the new touchstone for TAI’s assessment of US Presidents. So I can’t really evaluate the Brazil situation until I know the answer.

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2017 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service