Innovation Imperiled
Patent Trolls Cost Start-Ups Billions
show comments
  • ShadrachSmith

    Loser pays is the obvious solution.
    And IRS investigations of the trolling lawyers 🙂

    • mgoodfel

      “Loser Pays” means you don’t dare sue a big company, even if they are screwing you over. They have more money for lawyers, will pay their lawyers more, and if they win, you are ruined before you can appeal.

      • Richard T

        “Loser pays” simply means you have to persuade some wealthy lawyer that your suit is likely to win. Real inventors stand a fair chance of doing this: lawyers don’t get that wealthy by being stupid or ignorant.

      • ShadrachSmith

        Let’s compromise, let’s add full public disclosure of legal fees as a requirement for every class action judgment.

        • mgoodfel

          There are two basic causes for trolling: 1) the expense and uncertainty of the legal system, and 2) far too many garbage patents.

          There may not be much you can do about #1 (too many rich interests behind that one), but #2 could be solved by raising the bar on patents. If the legal system isn’t going to completely overwhelm innovation, patents need to be granted only on the really awesome, non-obvious, vital inventions. Not “one click ordering systems” and that sort of garbage.

          If patents were completely non-obvious, you wouldn’t have inadvertent duplication, it would be much clearer when you are infringing, and there would be a lot fewer patents.

          This system will change when companies start getting sued by the Chinese over their junk patents. Then American companies will suddenly realize what a stupid game this was.

    • Andrew Allison

      Right on the first count, but the IRS is too busy acting as the enforcement arm of the so-called “Democratic” party and expensive junkets to trouble itself with important stuff.

  • LarryD

    What has been forgotten is that Patents are supposed to “advance science and industry” by encouraging the publication of an inventions details so it can be eventually built upon by others.

    The American Patent system has become the playground of rent seekers.

  • Ann_NY

    This has already been done. You can’t just submit a one page patent and expect it to be granted. We have patents for our company that are hundreds of pages long with detailed images. Our patent attorney has an engineering background so he can walk the official through the process of implementing the devices so they understand how it works. The laws were changed after Research in Motion lost to one of those patent troll companies a few years back.

  • SeanInNYC

    No doubt the patent trolls create shell companies to launch the suits that can just declare bankruptcy and never have to pay a cent towards the defendant’s legal fees. This win may be “something” from an ideological or ethical perspective, but I couldn’t imagine any impact on the patent trolls.

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2017 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.