Delivering Health
Doctors Should Do Less Work
show comments
  • Andrew Allison

    “One way to help lower the cost of health care delivery is for doctors to work less.” seems hardly likely to endear the concept to Doctors who, at least in private practice, get paid per capita. A more enticing sales pitch might be that it allows them to see a larger number of patients who actually need their skills.

  • Boritz

    Watch the pricing model. Prediction: There may be a cost break in the beginning but one day you will wake up and find you are paying as much (or more) to see an ancillary team-member as you once paid to see a doctor. There will be studies to determine whether quality of care has suffered as a result of the new model. These studies will show whatever those who ordered them want them to show. Will my dog still get to see the guy with 8 years of college? How about going to see the doctor means going to see the doctor.

    • qet

      Yes, I agree with this, especially in the context of the gradual absorption of doctors into hospital corporations as salaried employees as described in a Via Meadia post from last week. The hospital corporations will acquire all medical service providers eventually, and the costs savings to them from paying non-MDs less than MDs to provide care will be retained by their executive administrations and not passed along to consumers. See Colleges & Universities, US.

      • Andrew Allison

        I think that the issue of doctors moving to salaried positions within hospital corporations needs more study. We’ve had doctors working as salaried employees at, e.g. HMOs, in parallel with private practice for a very long time.

        Doctors are abandoning private practice, at least in part, because of the overhead. Making their work environment more satisfying (by letting others to routine work) would mitigate this.

  • mgoodfel

    As someone with chronic medical problems (paraplegic), there are times I just want routine care and would take it from a nurse-practitioner without complaint. There are other times when I want a doctor. I really don’t want a system where you get the NP all the time, and have to escalate problems to the doctor.

    From the doctor’s point of view, there are two problems. Will the NP know when they are in over their heads? And will they spot that rare symptom which indicates trouble?

    I also think it will be difficult to get good at being a primary care doctor if you only get the hard cases, or only spend your time reviewing test results. Experience with routine problems seems necessary if you want to distinguish those from the complex cases.

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2017 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.