Jobs of the Future in One Astounding Graph
show comments
  • wigwag

    “Nurse practitioners and home health workers are paid well, but still much less than doctors are.” ( Walter Russell Mead)

    While nurse practitioners are very well paid, it is simply factually inaccurate to claim that home health care workers are well paid; the vast majority are not. Most home health care workers are low skilled and earn low wages, often at or near the minimum wage. While there are exceptions (e.g. physical and occupational therapists who come to the patient’s home), the exceptions are few and far between. A particular irony is that many home health care workers get no fringe benefits and don’t receive health insurance for themselves or their families.

    One of the reasons that there are so many new jobs for home health care workers is that the American population is aging and as people get older they are more likely to need these kind of services. Changing bed pans, helping the elderly take showers and providing old people with assistance to get dressed and undressed is labor intensive and not especially susceptible to technology induced improvements in productivity.

    The idea that there is any kernel of optimism in the report that Professor Mead cites in this post, just doesn’t stand up to scrutiny.

    • Corlyss

      In your experience, are most of the home health care workers foreigners? I had my mother in a nursing home where all but the activities leader and the RN were foreign-born whose English was poor to nonexistent. Making oneself understood by them was a task in itself. Made me wonder if the home care workers were equally challenging.

      • wigwag

        I have only my own experience to go by; I’ve had family members and friends assisted by home health care workers. Some needed long term assistance while others needed it only for a few weeks. The locations of the people using these services were New York, New Jersey and South Florida. I would say that most of the home health care workers were foreign born, but not all were. It’s only a generalization and there were exceptions, but I would say that for the most part, though they had poorer communications skills, the foreign born home health care workers were more attentive, diligent and respectful of their elderly patients than the American born home health care workers were.

  • Corlyss

    So that’s what’s to become of America: we’re “evolving” into a care industry with a military (and we won’t have that for long at the rate the peaceniks and the budget hawks are collapsing it).

    • Jim__L

      “Imperial overstretch” is dead. We’re going through a period where great powers will fall because their social spending bankrupts them, not because their military expenditures are too big.

  • Christopher Perrey

    I’d wager most of these jobs are in the insurance/regulatory oversight positions (“our new overlords”) or more menial-type positions in the medical field (cleaning, bedpans, etc.).

    Given the medical device tax, regulatory overhead, and low returns on investment, these positions are certainly not in the medical device/pharma industry with good-paying R&D positions.

  • USNK2

    I am self-censoring my comment on Mr. Mead’s delusions about health care into: may he have all of his good doctors drop him when he gets stuck with Medicare, and may he then enter the bizarro world where a vacation in Syria seems like a better solution than ever going to another nursepractitioner again.

  • Boritz

    The jobs of the future may be in this sector, or that sector, or yet again some other sector, but there is no doubt that more jobs will be part-time and lacking good benefits.

  • Jim__L

    If more people are collecting paychecks (especially “good paychecks”), that means the system is getting more expensive.

    More expensive is something we aren’t going to be able to handle.

    That blue line is likely to see a dip of its own, in the next decade or two.

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2017 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.