Coming Soon To Club Med: Scrip?
show comments
  • Kenny

    If introduced, script will be another means of incrementally ratcheting down of the wealth & living standards in those countries that resort to it.

    Those who accept the script will never realize its full, ‘promised’ value. The script will only be a means of getting through the day.

    Why will anyone accept script? Because, they have no choice.

  • chase

    Professor, you should propose a solution, or perhaps several hypothetical solutions.

  • Jacksonian Libertarian

    We have seen this in California, America’s Greece. It’s just a method of kicking the can down the road, and does nothing to solve the problems which created the need to use script in the first place. Eventually everyone that accepts Greek script will be forced to take Drachma’s for it, or not get paid at all.

  • vanderleun

    Scrip could reappear and then so could wheelbarrows full of bundles of scrip carted around the city to buy a pack of smokes.

  • Mrs. Davis

    How is scrip different from Federal Reserve Notes?

  • GC

    This is where you hit the nail on the head:
    “Greece has no course open to it today that doesn’t result in a colossal mess with lots of suffering all round.”
    This is true not only for Greece but for all governments that are excessively indebted, including the US.
    The economists writing op-eds for the US media urge us to take on more debt in order to fuel more deficit spending in order to avoid “lots of suffering all round.”
    No, there is no way to avoid the coming storms. We have a choice: stay on our current ship of state – the one that has brought us to where we are – or abandon ship and board a smaller, more stable and enduring vessel. Yes, either way we’re in for a very rough ride, but if we seize the moment and take some risks we will come out of this stronger and healthier rather than weaker and more vulnerable to future crises.
    More debt and more interest payments are not solutions.
    “In the 40 years from 1970 through 2010, our elected representatives in
    Congress and the White House spent $5.7 trillion on interest payments
    on the national debt. In the 2000 – 2010 period, they spent $2.2 trillion.
    Based on CBO’s interest rate forecast for the 2012 – 2021 period, they
    will spend $5.5 trillion on interest payments in the 2012 – 2021 period.”
    page 46 The National Debt: A Primer and A Plan (Booklocker, 2011).

  • Kis

    I believe the Greek word for scrip is “Drachma”.

  • Kevin

    If merchants are forced to accept script at face value it will instantly lead to an all cash (script) economy. (I am assuming script will make up a significant fraction of the money in circulation, which it will have to to have much affect.) No one will part with Euros when they could spend the same face value of script. This means no use use checks or credit cards for consumer transactions. It would probably also seize up the commercial lending market. Who would barrow in Euros for business if their revenue will come in script the bank won’t accept for repayment. If banks are forced to accept script in return for Euro loans, interest rates will go through the roof to reflect the lower value of script.

    I suspect a clean switch over to Drachmas would work out better. It would destroy a lot of stored value but if done wel should allow the economy to begin functioning again.

    An even better solution might be to kick Germany and other fiscally responsible states out of the Euro and leave the Club Med countries with the weak and devaluing currency their politics seems to require. The advantage of this over the weaker states leaving is that it would avoid a lot of litigation and/or defaults over debts owed in Euros. Sure it would screw over creditors but they are going to get shafted sooner or later anyway.

    In any case Europe clearly needs an open policy of acknowledging unpleasant truths rather than papering them over and hoping the nightmare will just go away. That and maybe prosecuting a generation of Greek poloiticians and bureaucrats who cooked the books to hide national debt.

  • Kenny

    From Wikipedia:

    Gresham’s law is an economic principle that states: “When a government compulsorily overvalues one type of money and undervalues another, the undervalued money will leave the country or disappear from circulation into hoards, while the overvalued money will flood into circulation.”[1] It is commonly stated as: “Bad money drives out good”, but is more accurately stated: “Bad money drives out good if their exchange rate is set by law.”

  • Snorri Godhi

    Issuing scrip or Californian IOUs, like going back to the drachma, is just a way to cut public spending and will not necessarily have much of an impact on the private sector.
    When the State pays its employees and contractors in devaluing scrip/IOUs/drachmas, it is maintaining constant nominal spending while cutting real spending.
    Meanwhile, the private sector happily keeps using some medium of exchange that is also useful as a unit of account and store of value.

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2017 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.