Africa: Triumph of Democracy?
show comments
  • Anthony

    “Many things will happen in Africa in the 21st century…” WRM, an AI colleague intimates countries/institutions are what they are because actors in any given society have an in interest in keeping them that way – clientelism, patrimonialism, history, ethnic conflict, etc.

  • Brett

    It’s too soon to tell with Mali, since the replacement regime is both unpopular and looking very frail.

  • John Burke

    WRM makes a good point, but I think he is buying into a framework for looking at this and other African issues that is the wrong one. The Tuareg mercenaries have staged a coup against the democratic government of a nation-state, Mali.

    But the Tuareg are a Berber people, traditionally nomadic, about six million strong who 100 years ago wandered about much of the Sahara. They resisted French colonial overlordship, pretty effectively until they were finally suppressed and pacified. In the post-1960 decolonialization period, France and the more populous groups within French West Africa created a cluster of new nations which divided the Tuareg among six such states, with the largest numbers in Mali and Niger. The Malian Tuareg never much cared to be ruled by a government run by the major Black sub-Saharan populations and staged several revolts — before this one.

    I think this should be seen as a continuation of Tuareg resistance, this time with better weapons, not as a coup.

    Of course, this problem of incompatible populations stuffed into the same polity is at the heart of virtually every violent conflict in Africa for the past 40 years. But the Western state system — now validated by the UN and a host of other international structures — isn’t flexible enough to enable change. The recent emergence of South Sudan may offer a new precedent. Let’s hope so.

  • Kris

    I don’t need to be spoon-fed, but perhaps this post elides too much. One could easily reach [email protected]’s mistaken conclusion: that this was a Tuareg coup. (As opposed to a military coup under the reason/pretext that the civilian leadership was mishandling the Tuareg insurrection.)

    Irony alert: Mali’s last democratic order was established after a military coup (and popular protests). The leader of that coup, which did indeed bring about relative democracy, was Amadou Toumani Toure, Mali’s current/deposed president.

  • Jacksonian Libertarian

    “Cultures evolve at Glacial Speeds” Jacksonian Libertarian

    The backward cultures of Africa have a long way to go before they will begin to resemble the advanced Western Cultures, let alone the Bleeding Edge American Culture.

    Calling Mali a stable Democracy when the country had never seen a democratic change in leadership, is a very loose definition of Democracy.

    We have all seen nascent Democracy’s backslide into Authoritarianism. So a better definition of a Democracy isn’t “one vote one time”, but a change in a nation’s leadership, from one party to another unrelated party. The key word here is “Change” as in a Democratic Change in leadership, from one elected leadership, to another elected leadership. Only when a Democracy can change its leadership, can it truly be called a Democracy. By this definition Mali was not a Democracy, as it had never Changed its leadership.

  • Albert

    Jacksonian Libertarian:

    A democratic change in leadership, from one elected leadership, to another elected leadership did occur in Mali. Alpha Oumar Konare served the maximum two terms in office (1992-1997 & 1997-2002) permitted under the country’s constitution. The democratic transfer of power occurred in 2002, when Amadou Toumani Toure was elected president. He was re-elected in 2007 and the country was only a month away from holding new elections. Unlike the trend in other African countries where leaders try to cling to power by removing term limits or altering the constitutional laws, there were no indications of this taking place in Mali prior to the coup.

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2017 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.