Afghan Forces to Defect to Taliban?
show comments
  • Kenny

    I sure this is true — if not now then eventually.

    And we can thank the community organizer in the Oval Office. He has screwed up the economy and now he’s making a mess of foreign affaires.

  • John Burke

    It is not a claim to ignore. The storied “Afghan way of war” relies heavily on going with the flow. Many of the Afghan troops (though not the Arab and other foreigners) fighting with the Taliban as of 9/11/01 had changed sides two or three times since the Soviet pullout. Many changed again as US bombs and missiles pummeled them, surrendering to various “Northern Alliance” forces. Most went home for awhile only to reappear on the battlefield as either Taliban or members of the new national army. By and large, these guys follow local leaders of their subclans or “warlords” (which is much the same thing). Indeed, it would be surprising if they were not keeping in touch with the Taliban,

  • Mrs. Davis

    Remember Elphinstone.

  • Tom Holsinger

    Nothing has changed. This is normal in Afghanistan. You can’t _buy_ Afghans. You can only rent them for as long as they feel doing whatever for you as opposed to someone else, or just for the jollies themselves.

  • JeremyR

    There’s very little difference ideologically between the Taliban and the Afghans we are supporting (who do things like force women to marry their rapist).

    Afghans are determined to be in the stone age.

  • Cunctator

    Should we be surprised? The West’s war aims never took account of the socio-political realities on the ground.

  • Walter Sobchak

    Of course they will. The Taliban is the armed militia of the Pashtun ethnos. It is funded and trained by the Pakistani military and intelligence establishments, who are also dominated by Pashtuns. The surprising thing is that the Pakistanis are not begging to make a deal. But, I think they prefer having American hostages.

    What I would do is to get all Americans out of Afghanistan ASAP, and once they were out, I would obliterate the Pakistani military’s physical assets. Then, I would cut off their aid and send a letter to India telling them that Pakistan and Afghanistan are their problem, and that we do not care what they do with the Pakistanis who are a rum lot, and are not to be trusted.

  • So maybe a sudden unannounced withdrawal would be better? It would certainly be cheaper.

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2017 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.