More Queens, Please
show comments
  • Kenny

    Mr Mead, do you give any credence to the idea that the British monarchy is a continuation of Kin David’s line and that’s what the Stone of Scone is all about????

    If so, it is hard to see how it could ever be abolished.

    • Walter Russell Mead

      @Kenny: Never heard of this before and if there were anything to it, I think some intimation of the fact would have crossed my desk by now. As far as I know, King David’s line is established on high and doesn’t need any help from the UK.

  • “The ultimate way to modernize a monarchy is to abolish it.”

    The 20th move away from monarchy was one of many stupid things that led to disaster. A constitutionally limited monarchy, is the best form of government, for many reasons. The USA has a king-like president, but it is not a good way to do things. Look around the world and it is obvious: The monarchies are the best countries in their regions. In the middle ages the King was bound by an oath and was in effect a constitutional monarch. Only in the early modern period did kingship and despotism become linked. Modernity is nothing to write home about. Monarchy will not be abolished and should not be.

  • joe

    The King’s consort a Papist? Not in my green and pleasant Albion, thank you very much. Next thing they’ll want to nationalise the Queen’s swans. Red idolators each one and suffragette supporters apparently

  • Mrs. Davis

    Muslim consorts OK? Druid? After all, who cares to whom the head of the established church is married? At that point disestablish the church and make it a secular republic. Or apply for statehood by county.

  • Mrs. Davis

    And here I thought this was going to be about the glorious borough.

  • Jim.

    There’s no reason to abolish the monarchy. It’s part of the landscape of England. If the monarchy (or aristocracy) finds itself becoming unpopular in England, all they really need to do is stop dipping into the tax revenues of the nation.

    Just look how popular they are in America — now that they don’t tax us anymore.

  • Andrew Allison

    As noted @Jim, the monarchy is part of the fabric of Britain (and 15 other nations). A more thoughtful subject of discussion might be its evolution, which seems to this observer increasingly likely to turn on a generation-skip. I, for one, would be more interested in Prof. Mead’s thoughts on the American political aristocracy which, at least until recently, had less turnover than the House of Lords!

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2017 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.