Religious Tolerance In Egypt's Al-Azhar University
show comments
  • Unfortunately Dr. al-Tayeb’s opinions on this subject are far from being in the majority.

  • Jim.

    The simple fact is that in this life, not everyone is going to agree (with you), and you have to find a way to deal constructively with that.

    Christ gave us the Parable of the Sower; this should be taken to heart by everyone who tries their hand at persuasion of any type.

  • Paul

    I must second Mr. Hoffman’s point. Yes, there are certainly verses in the Qu’ran which appear directly supportive of this position. There are also verses which appear even more directly opposed to it. It is the task of the mujtahid (or at least the ulama, depending on one’s tradition) to make the proper judgment as to which applies. The influential orthodox schools do not take the position of at-Tayab.

    On the issue of Muslim tolerance and “moderation,” Mr. Mead very frequently puts himself in the somewhat pathetic position of a person who cites those few “progressive” Jesuits and other religious, particularly modernist American nuns, who advocate for the ordination of lesbian priests, and so forth. Yes, there are those with their origins in the tradition who advocate these courses. However, they are regarded as apostates by the orthodox within that tradition, and their recommendations are rejected. Over time, they may win out — but the time-frame involved is measured by multiple generations. Mr. Mead seems ever willing to “hold his breath” for eschaton of Muslim peace which is just around the corner. It is difficult to avoid the impression that he is grasping at straws.

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2017 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.