The Unicorn of Peace Isn't Visiting Kashmir
show comments
  • Riki Tiki Tavi

    “And so, partly to keep us happy, they talk.” Touche’.

    What prevents peace from breaking out between Pakistan and India? Is Kashmir the root cause of hostilities, or a symptom? I think you are forgetting that paying lip-service to Pakistan’s claims on Kashmir was how America paid off its client diplomatically during the heydays of the cold war. I doubt American analysts really ever believed that Kashmir was the “core” issue between the two countries. It was just a convenient talking point to keep India on the defensive, and so India talked endlessly! Mr. Fai’s (head of the Kashmiri American Council, in the pay of the ISI) recent arrest is indicative that the United States never took Pakistan’s narrative on Kashmir too seriously.

    The fundamental unresolved matter in South Asia is, “how will Muslims and non-Muslims live with one another?” This question has been asked many times in that part of the world, and to which many answers have been given. The latest answer, upon which Pakistan is founded, is the two-nation theory, which by its very design and content can only lead to implacable hostility between Muslims and Hindus, and other non-Muslim faiths as well. What is it that the Kashmiri Muslim cannot have in a democratic India that he feels he can either as part of Pakistan, or in an independent Kashmir? The answer is Sharia, plain and simple. No, he cannot have Sharia in India, which is why expulsion of Hindus from the Kashmir Valley, the only Muslim majority portion of the state of Jammu and Kashmir, was such a high priority.

    If India, Pakistan, and the United States need to talk, it is about Pakistan’s transformation into a more tolerant, democratic country. Kashmir would automatically resolve itself in due course. But, I’m afraid Pakistan has gone too far down the fundamentalist road for the two-nation theory to be repudiated nonviolently. Instead of waiting for talks on Kashmir to bear fruit, the United States and India need to start preparing for potentially dire events in South Asia.

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2017 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites.