mead cohen berger shevtsova garfinkle michta grygiel blankenhorn
The Francis Era
Synod of Bishops Ends, Church Stays Catholic

The now-infamous 2014 Catholic Synod of Bishops on marriage and the family ended this weekend, and anyone who was waiting with bated breath for some kind of change in Catholic doctrine or practice will have to keep waiting—perhaps indefinitely. Going into the Synod, by far the biggest question under discussion was whether remarried Catholics should be allowed to receive communion, with some Catholic clergy strenuously advocating for a relaxation of the current prohibition. When a preliminary draft of a report on the discussion was released last week, midway through the gathering, some of the language about cohabiting couples and homosexuals caused a stir. The American media got excited over what they saw as a shift in the Church’s sexual ethics, while traditionalists were dismayed by what they saw as a betrayal of the Church’s mission of clearly articulating the Catholic position.

At the time, we argued that much of the reaction was more heat than light. Nothing in the document, which was itself non-binding, signaled a shift in Catholic doctrine. We also argued that a final report would probably reflect the criticisms many Catholics had about the tone of the interim report. That seems to be exactly what happened, via the NYT:

The preliminary version of the report set off a furor, with phrases implying that the church was shifting toward understanding and acceptance of gay couples. Earlier on Saturday, before the final report was issued, Cardinal Gianfranco Ravasi of Italy said it would be “welcoming” to gays, but not approving of them. […]

The final document drops the language in the preliminary draft that spoke of “welcoming” gays and that they had “gifts and qualities to offer to the Christian community.” The final version says that gays must be met with “respect and sensitivity,” phrasing also in the church’s catechism, but emphatically asserts there is no basis whatsoever for comparing same-sex unions to marriage between a man and a woman.

The Synod may leave some observers with the suspicion that this was just the first step in the Vatican’s slow move to liberalize its teachings. Insofar as old issues once considered closed under John Paul II and Benedict XIV now appear to be “up for discussion” again, that may be a reasonable response. But when push comes to shove, next year’s larger gathering of Bishops on this same topic is likely to end just the way this one did: with a re-affirmation of Catholic doctrine mixed up with enough nods towards pastoral mercy and openness to leave everyone clinging to some sense of victory.

Features Icon
show comments
  • Nathaniel Greene

    Pope Francis is in over his head. This is a defeat for him and reflects just how out of touch he is with the vast majority of bishops and catholic communicants.

    • FriendlyGoat

      Francis has delighted the world by reminding us all (Catholics and non-Catholics) why “The Church” even exists. (Hint: It’s not to empower a bunch of Bishops in clubby little local kingdoms.) Some of the Catholics don’t like that, which is truly unfortunate.

  • PDX_traveler

    water dripping on a stone will, over time, shape the stone. Most people do not view things in the longer term, but fret not: the church will follow its flock as much as lead: as it has in the past, it will in the future. No firm succeeded by ignoring its customers.

  • TheCynical1

    As the saying goes, “Love the sinner, hate the sin.” That’s all I see here. This concept went right over the heads of both the media and the traditionalists, with both camps misinterpreting greater love for sinners as greater love for sins.

    • jeburke

      They don’t believe there is such a thing as sin, so it’s impossible for them to understand Christians.

  • FriendlyGoat

    Whether you look at government bureaucracies, police departments, prison management, the military-industrial complex or large Church denominations, the middle management is often where the pains in the butt reside and thrive. A church run by its bishops will always be a disappointment.

    This Pope has stepped out with the priorities of real evangelism and a focus on concern for the world’s poor. Those priorities are the ones suffering as the Bishops demand to worry more about their traditions than anything important.

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2016 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service