mead berger shevtsova garfinkle michta grygiel blankenhorn bayles
Public Opinion
American Support for Israel Getting More Partisan

Is support for Israel becoming a partisan cause? According to a new brief from the Pew Research Center, public opinion is moving steadily in that direction:

Views of Israel and the Palestinians have become more ideologically polarized. In early September 2001, just before the 9/11 terrorist attacks, there were only modest partisan and ideological differences in Israeli-Palestinian sympathies. But since then, and especially over the past decade, the share sympathizing more with Israel than with the Palestinians has increased among all ideological groups, with the exception of liberal Democrats.

While overall support for Israel has actually grown over the past several decades, the distribution of that support has changed, with critics of the Jewish State increasingly concentrated in the Democratic Party, and its champions increasingly concentrated in the GOP. The fact that Israel policy has grown more polarized and contentious probably makes the conspiratorial “Israel lobby” thesis more attractive to liberals living in echo chambers. They have lost cultural contact with the mass of Americans who are strongly supportive of the Jewish State, so the idea of a Jewish cabal pulling strings behind the scenes seems like a rational way to explain the special bond that the two nations still enjoy.

Israel-Palestine is still a relatively marginal issue in American elections, and the changing partisan dynamics won’t translate directly into policy shifts. After all, the Democrats are on the cusp of nominating a candidate who is by all accounts more hawkish on Israel-related issues than the current president, and the Republicans have nominated someone who seems personally indifferent to the Arab-Israeli conflict, and who has excited the traditionally anti-Israel (and worse) “America First” wing of the GOP. Still, in the long run, the trend is a cause for some concern for the U.S.-Israel bond, which has been able to thrive in part because of the Jewish State’s bipartisan appeal. The latest polling trends—if they persist—could make the relationship more fractious and unpredictable.

Features Icon
show comments
  • Felix Keverich

    LOL @ “Jewish State’s bipartisan appeal”

    Can anyone explain to me what is so appealing about Jewish ethnonationalism? I can understand why US Jews might see the benefit in having a “Jewish state”, where they could take refuge from the next Holocaust, but what’s the upside to a typical American goy?

    • GS

      ” but what’s the upside to a typical American goy?”-

      Civilizational affinity: a besieged outpost of the Western civ, and a nice testing ground for quite a lot of interesting stuff.

      • Felix Keverich

        That’s really stupid reason to dump billions of dollars in aid to Israel every year. Israel is a high-maintenance ‘ally’.

        • GS

          At least an ally, and not a third-world cesspool grabbing aid and returning nothing for it. Here one gets some feedback on, for example, urban warfare [who else has had that kind of experience recently?], or the battle-testing of systems like arrow and iron dome. Hopefully, the development of a tunnel detection systems would also be useful. And add the intel info on the moslem lands – in view of 9/11 that’s valuable, too.

          • Felix Keverich

            “urban warfare [who else has had that kind of experience recently?]”
            Ummm, Iraq war doesn’t count? US had to fight some real terrorists in Iraq, not just kids with Kalashnikovs.

            I think I know you, GS. You’re a Jew from Russia (we had a talk about Russophobia before). But I was asking for a gentile perspective.

          • GS

            And when was Iraq? The late Chief Chris Kyle is no longer in service.

  • FriendlyGoat

    “Liberal Democrats” should have figured out by now that the entirety of Islam is a crock—–BECAUSE—-it is NOT liberal and in fact has a built-in goal of world-wide domination of liberals in submission to something “not liberal”. If this was not true, the Palestinian situation would have been solved decades ago and everyone over there would be going peacefully hand in hand. So, if there are still hold-outs on the Left side (my side) who think Islam will be nicer when it is treated nicer by free people——DUDES, WAKE UP.

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2017 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service