Battle for India
Modi’s Million-Job Challenge
show comments
  • Andrew Allison

    The first three paragraph of the article linked to point to a further difficulty faced by India, namely that the labor content of much manufacturing has declined significantly. What is said to be the largest forge, in Pune, is run by hundreds of
    engineers, not tens of thousands of laborers. If India is to create unskilled jobs, they will have be in labor-intensive industries that are likely to remain that way. Agriculture and Infrastructure perhaps?

    • El Gringo

      Over half of all working Indians are employed in agricultural sectors, yet agriculture only makes up 17% of the Indian economy. The average size of landholdings is already less than 5 acres. The last thing Indian agriculture needs is more farmers.

      Infrastructure and heavy industry may be a solution but cutting through India’s green and saffron tape makes this an unlikely avenue. Take POSCO’s history-making $12 billion dollar investment deal inked in 2005 that has yet to break ground.

      • Andrew Allison

        Good point about agriculture; but perhaps if the farms were more productive, they would employ more labor. As I noted, heavy industry, which increasingly employs hundreds of skilled workers versus thousands of unskilled ones, is not the answer. What India needs is labor-intensive unskilled employment.

  • Anthony

    India remains a complex country: world largest democracy; parliamentary government; 28 states; 16th national election. Narendra Modi cannot be expected to work miracles that predecessors were incapable of. India and Modi will survive and adjust as the sub-continent has – Modi may be signal contrast to Singh.

    • El Gringo

      Modi and India will undoubtedly survive. But Indians in general, and the younger generation in particular, are getting very tired at merely surviving. They want more from life and they are going to start expecting more from their leadership.

      • Anthony

        The phrase used rhetorically and includes your stated position.

  • Jaldhar Vyas

    Troves of Roman coins have been discovered in the area of the Gujarati city of Bharuch (Barygaza in Latin.) When the Parsis fled Muslim persecution in Iran, they came to Gujarat. The Portugese established trading posts in Daman and Div which are Union Territories but geographically in Gujarat. The British soon followed and the East India Companies first HQ was in Surat in Gujarat. In my hometown of Rajkot there was until the establishment of Israel a synagogue founded by “Baghdadis” Jews from Iran and Iraq who took part in the diamond trade which is largely the preserve of Jain merchants from Gujarat.

    The point of mentioning all this is that Gujarati economic sucess is the result of a long-standing relatively cosmopolitan, entrepreneurial culture which simply does not exist in most parts of India. Elements of both the left and right are enamoured of the “great man” theory of politics but history shows us that culture is paramount and culture cannot be arbitrarily changed or indeed changed at all without mighty effort. Hopefully Modi can begin the task of turning India around but it’ll take a lot more than one man to make a difference.

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2017 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites.