Higher Ed Transformation
UK Labour Party Proposes Debt-Free Degree
show comments
  • qet

    Don’t forget about Ye Olde Piper & Tune, the pub that will be serving this student clientele. This is a Labour proposal. Can you imagine: there will have to be strict gender, racial and other quotas for these “free” degrees. Assuming the “education” (sorry, but nearly every term needs setting off by quote marks, not scare quotes but quotes indicating the substance of the concept indicated by the word may not be what it traditionally has been) is not just vo-tech but includes some humanities and social sciences, can you imagine a Labour government (or even the present Conservative/Liberal coalition) permitting students to take courses that don’t emphasize white privilege, the prevalent rape culture, the oppression by the English of brown peoples all over the world, the environmental crimes committed daily by the West on the Rest of the World,, the social injustice perpetrated by each and every white European male—living or dead–just by getting out of bed every morning, just by reason of his mere existence? No–the humanities will be too much a battle ground, and any such proposal must eventually limit itself to STEM and probaby just a subset of that. After all, I once read a complaint by a Latino activist that the schools in Latino-dominated communities should teach “Aztec” math, that Western math was just a continuation of the North’s oppression of the South. This kind of thing will infect the UK proposal. Why don’t we all just welcome the return of Craft Guilds and apprenticeships, which served Western economies well except for a small slice of our history of about one century.

  • Andrew Allison

    There seems to be an inconsistacy in your thinking here. Earlier today you wrote about the excess of PhDs. In the past you have written about the over-abundance of higher education and its cost, and yet here you applaud a proposal to add fuel to the fire.

  • Jim__L

    If Western Civ isn’t worth teaching — emphasizing! — then Humanities aren’t worth teaching.

  • Boritz

    It would be bad if the commercial world remade the academy in its image. However, we are presently so far from this state that the pendulum needs to swing a little bit in the direction of practicum. Professors are often so poorly informed about the world outside of academics even in their own field that they couldn’t give students the kind of real-world preparation they need even if they wanted to. This kind of insulation can’t be abided in fields like medicine and dentistry where graduates need to have a solid grounding in the real world from day one on the job. For most fields the educational experience provides no such grounding and the graduates spend years learning what they need to know on-the-job. Improving this situation would definitely be a good thing.

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2017 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.