Immigrants are Assimilating, Just Like Always
show comments
  • lukelea
  • Nick M.

    I had a professor/head of our poli sci dept (who is an Indian immigrant trying to get her citizenship no less) made it clear during one of our classes that we are the envy of Europe in terms of our immigration in how well we’ve done so far assimilating immigrant populations, and she agrees with that assessment (despite her frustration with the paperwork in trying to get her citizenship).

    • bfancher

      I don’t doubt it, but that’s a pretty low bar.

  • rheddles

    I increasingly fear we are good at integrating, not assimilating. The question is how much of their peonic Latin American culture our American culture will absord as our educational institutions fail to assimilate them into knowledge of and appreciation for that American culture is what I fear. As long as our elite does not believe in American exceptionalism, we will suffer cultural dilution.

  • SouthwesternSongDog

    Perhaps, but Latino immigrants are highly conscious of their ethnicity and vote reliably for the politicians who promise the most largess from the government. they are not conditioned to regard political promises with suspicion and seem to believe it’s “free” when it comes from the government.

  • VictorErimita

    The “pessimists” link is to an MSNBC article purporting to describe (as racist, of course) statements by someone at Heritage. All they quote him as saying is that Hispanics (along with Asians and others) have not become indistiguishable from white, as Irish and Italians have. Duh. If appearing to be white is the definition of assimilation, then ok, but isn’t it a little more complicated than that? I don’t trust MSNBC to present anything accurately, and my guess is the Heritage guy is not as simplistic, nor as racist, as the apparatchiks at MSNBC would like us to think.

    But does the Left want assimilation? Assimilation flows from the 18th Century notion of universal pluralism. Isn’t the contemporary “diversity” narrative all about pluralism, without the universal part? Isn’t it about not assimilating? What is identity politics, the core of leftism, about if not separation, division, alienation and resistance to assimilation (all, of course, while blaming the “far right”)?

  • jmatt55

    Is that so? So why when I visit Home Depot do I enter through the Entrada and exit through the Salida?

    Why do I have to press one for english?

    If I step into Walmart, why does it sound like I’m shopping in Ecuador?

    My family came from Italy. I’m pretty sure telephone operators didn’t ask phone users whether they would like to converse in English or Italian.

  • solotar

    Unfortunately, the author is dead wrong. The fact that Mexicans get their news from the MSM is meaningless. Mexicans perform very poorly in schools, even after multiple generations, they don’t start businesses, they have children out of wedlock, they break the law … all of this is “relative” to other immigrant groups. The reason is obvious: if you are forever surrounded by other Mexicans, if you are taught to feel the country you moved to was always yours, if your ballot and your everything is printed in Spanish, if your kids go to Spanish-speaking schools … blah blah blah why assimilate?

  • GSR

    Yeah, I believe polls. What a joke. Come to my neighborhood Mr Mead. You will never a never ending parade of hijabs, burkas, Mexican flags, La Raza bumper siickers, et. al.
    Time to slooow down legal immigration and deport illegal immigrants. Period.

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2017 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.