Race to the Top Hits Speed Bump
show comments
  • WigWag

    “Giving parents more power to pick schools is the better option.” (Walter Russell Mead and Team)

    Nope, more often than not, parents are part of the problem not part of the solution.

    Perhaps Professor Mead should re-read Charles Murray’s new book. Where parents are upper middle class and take an active interest in providing a structured, loving and education-intensive home life kids thrive in school no matter what type of schools they are.

    In Brookline, Massachusetts, Scarsdale, New York, Greenwich, Connecticut or Beverly Hills, California it doesn’t matter whether teachers are unionized or not; it doesn’t matter whether supervisors regularly observe teachers, it doesn’t matter whether the physical plants of public schools are ancient or modern and it doesn’t matter what curriculum or textbooks the schools use; kids thrive no matter what.

    The same thing is true in white, working class neighborhoods and minority neighborhoods. It doesn’t matter if teachers are unionized, it doesn’t matter if the physical plants of schools are modern or decrepit, it doesn’t matter whether teachers are observed by supervisors and it doesn’t matter what curriculum or text books are used; nothing works. The parents are usually the problem not the solution. Giving parents the ability to choose their children’s school is as apt to make things worse as it is to make things better.

    Bad parents make bad students regardless of what the public education system does.

    If you don’t believe it; read Charles Murray.

  • Anthony

    “This economic system cannot do without the ultimo ratio of the complete destruction of those existences which are irretrievably associated with the hopelessly unadapted” (Joseph Schumpeter).

    Transpose the above quote to education bureaucracy critiqued in WRM’s Quick Take…

  • Toni

    Ahem. The “federal government’s Race to the Top” is Obama’s baby. Shall we classify this attempt at social engineering as incompetent or outright inept?

    Texas knew better. It implemented school testing and teacher accountability long ago; they were the basis for Pres. Bush’s No Child Left Behind. Texas also knows better than to yield control to Washington leftists. From a National Review article on Texas’s economic success, in this case its reaction to part of Obama’s $832 billion stimulus:

    “Saying no at just the right time sometimes means turning down “free” money from
    Washington. Texas left $556 million on the table when the federal government offered it to help modernize Texas’s unemployment trust fund, because the deal would have forced state taxpayers to pour additional revenue into the system after Uncle Sam’s bequest was tapped out. “Thanks, but no thanks,” Newton says. “We know who is going to have to replenish those funds. That was an attempt to bribe us – to bribe us with our own money.””

  • Toni

    “Social engineering” was the wrong term. Perhaps “teacher’s union override” is better. But like Obamacare and Dodd-Frank, Race to the Top tries to micromanage, which makes it both a nightmare to try to implement and less effective than a simpler version would probably have been.

    I’m adding ineffective to incompetent and inept as descriptors of Obama’s job performance. Or are those redundant?

  • Kris

    The teachers’ unions object? How dare they?! Aren’t they in favor of education? Are they casting doubt on the good intentions and professionalism of their evaluator colleagues? Don’t they realize their complaints are playing into the hands of the Koch-funded libertarians who want to eliminate public education and return our children to a Dickensian dystopia?

    [/sarc]

  • lhf

    As reported in the Washington Post, a northern Virginia parent after spending a considerable amount of time volunteering on various school committees, got appointed to one on evaluating teachers. His suggestion was to have the first grade teacher(s) evaluate kindergarten, 2nd grade, 1st grade and on up based on whether or not the upcoming class had been prepared to do the next grade’s work. This seemingly sensible suggestion was opposed by teachers, mainly.

    I thought it was worth a look.

  • EvilBuzzard

    Race To The Top was an awesome success! People who have no desire to endure either the wages or the stress of a High School Math Teacher gig now get paid 3 to 4 times as much for 1/2 the work. That’s like killing it, dude!

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2017 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.