Time for the Confederate States of Europe?
show comments
  • JLK

    Dr Mead

    You are absolutely correct in your analysis of the EU. They are not ready for the kind of political union necessary to force a consistent corp. tax rate or a panoply of other federation rules that we here in the states take for granted. Ovr 2 dozen countries, all with different cultures and histories cannot agree on policies that would have such an impact on their economies, cultures, and societies without political union.

    (Lack of) Political union has always been the 800# gorilla in the corner that has been ignored until now. Lisbon was difficult enough but going forward with ever more transfers of political power to Brussels just ain’t gonna happen in our lifetime.

    I disagree with your optimism on this subject. My chrytal ball fogs up at this point, but I do know that Europe hitting this road block in a time of crisis means that events will dictate what happens in the future and not decisions made by the gnomes in Brussels.

    The Union has gone as far as it can ignoring the “gorilla’ and now it is either devolution or increased political union. They can’t stand still with Greece plus the PIIGS spriraling downward in the eyes of the bond markets, but they can’t move forward with the current economic union structure in place.

    Much to individual leaders dismay they must realize (I would hope) jogging in place is not an option at this stage. Eventually Italy will tank, Brussels will lose control and devolution will be forced on the “Grand Experiment”. But what takes it’s place is where my vision fails me.

  • bobby b

    “The requirement that all 27 member states . . . must agree to any significant change in the EU is a disaster waiting to happen. History moves faster than the EU these days.”

    Wasn’t there initially a requirement that the citizenry of all 27 member states vote their acceptance of their very place in the EU? Sort of a central issue, I would have thought, but in the face of difficulty, the EUocracy very neatly disposed of all that folderol.

    So, while I agree with you that that step is going to be a rather large drag on further evolution of the EU agreements – Poland’s liberum veto writ larger, really – my Inner Cynic tells me that the EUocracy can hold the rule out as an excuse as needed and also quickly whip it out of the way as they see fit.

  • Thank you WRM for your perspective. A cup of Java is good but your articles are better.

  • dearieme

    I think the Swiss Constitution might be held to have withstood fortune more successfully.

  • Anthony

    John Dewey: “Now it is true that social arrangements, laws, institutions are made for man…that they are means and agencies of human welfare and progress.” The import of this conception comes out in considering EU governance; Hegel provides insight into problem when he speaks of “National Territorial States” as consummation and culmination of man’s evolution vis-a-vis human social arrangements.

  • Jacksonian Libertarian

    The forces tearing the EU apart are much stronger than the forces holding it together. The US should be focused on creating a structure upon which to maintain trade throughout the EU states and the world, during the coming dislocation caused by the EU dissolution.

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2017 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.