mead cohen berger shevtsova garfinkle michta grygiel blankenhorn
Homage to Catalonia
An Independence Stalemate?

Sunday’s parliamentary elections in Catalonia, which were billed as a referendum on the region’s secession from Spain, produced mixed results. A group of pro-independence parties called “Together for Yes” captured 62 out of the Parliament’s 135 seats, but did so with less than 50 percent of the vote. If “Together for Yes” can form a coalition with CUP, a secessionist party on the Left, the pro-independence forces will have a majority of seats under their control. That has emboldened the leader of the independence movement, Artur Mas, to declare a “democratic mandate” for independence. NYT:

“We have a democratic mandate; we have won against all odds,” Artur Mas, the Catalan leader, told supporters in central Barcelona on Sunday night as votes were still being counted. “Just as we, as democrats, would have accepted defeat, we ask that others recognize the victory of Catalonia and the victory of the Yes” bloc for independence, he added […]

Raül Romeva, leader of the “Yes” list, told supporters on Sunday that “nobody can say that we don’t have legitimacy.”

But it’s an open question whether a coalition with CUP will work out. And, perhaps more importantly, the supposed democratic mandate is also in question: Wining an absolute majority was seen as crucial to the legitimacy of the independence movement leading up to the vote. In some ways, this was the worst possible result. A long, bad-tempered struggle likely lies ahead.

Features Icon
show comments
  • Andrew Allison

    Of course there’s no democratic mandate. The real news was the appalling performance of the ruling PP party, which suggests a change in government for Spain in December.

  • Tom

    (Sighs) Someone needs to go back and look at the actual election results. There were three pro-independence parties running, and together they won a majority of the seats and a majority of the voters.
    It is possible that I misunderstood what I read, mind, but still.

    • Andrew Allison

      48% of the voters.

      • Tom

        From what I could gather–and again, I could be wrong here:
        There’s “Together for yes”–62 seats, 39.5% of the vote; “Catalonia Yes We Can”: 11 seats, 8.9% of the vote; and the CUP, with 10 seats and 8.2% of the vote.
        Now, it is my understanding that Catalonia Yes We Can is a pro-independence party.

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2016 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service