mead cohen berger shevtsova garfinkle michta grygiel blankenhorn
Asia's Game of Thrones
China Shoots Philippine Boats with Water Cannon

China has scored some big wins lately in the rollout of its new infrastructure bank, the AIIB, as well as in its massive deal with Pakistan. But these headline grabbing bits of soft power diplomacy don’t mean that China has backed off its aggressive territorial agenda in the South China Sea. After something of a lull, Chinese ships are once again getting pushy with the ships of their South China Sea neighbors. Reuters reports:

The presidential palace in Manila said China’s coast guard used water cannon on Monday to drive away a group of Filipino fishermen at Scarborough Shoal, damaging some of their wooden boats. Chinese ships rammed a fishing boat in the area a few months back. […]

“China has no right to use water cannon on the poor fishermen,” Renato Reyes, secretary-general of left-wing activist group Bayan (Nation), said in a statement, while criticizing the government’s dependence on the U.S. military to protect the country.

China has done this kind of thing before, but this round of “water wars” is perhaps more significant because Philippine and U.S. troops are currently holding major combat exercises. The drills are intended “to simulate the re-taking of an island occupied by enemy forces in northwestern Zambales province,” according to Philippine officials. The official line from both sides is that these drills have nothing to do with China’s recent belligerence or its land reclamation projects in waters claimed by the Philippines, but we should take these disavowals with several grains of salt. The Air Force Times:

Shortly before overseeing the start of the military exercises, Philippine military chief Gen. Gregorio Pio Catapang Jr. held a news conference to release surveillance photos showing Chinese reclamation of eight previously submerged reefs in the disputed Spratly Islands, saying Beijing’s actions increase the risk of an accidental confrontation.

“We have compelling reasons to raise our voice to tell the whole world the adverse effects of China’s aggressiveness that has created tensions not only among the countries who have overlapping claims in the area,” Catapang said.

China may now be mixing in a bit more carrot with the stick, but none of the conditions that make East Asia a geopolitical powder keg have gone away.

Features Icon
show comments
  • Anthony

    An observation regarding implied inference underlying post interpretation: “potential tensions between an established and rising power are not new. Inevitably, the rising power impinges on some spheres heretofore treated as the exclusive preserve of the established power. By the same token, the rising power suspects that its rival may seek to quash its growth before it is too late…Both sides are reinforced in their suspicions by the military maneuvers and defense programs of the other…Each side has a responsibility for taking care lest its unilateral deployments and conduct….”

    “Chinese thinking is shaped in part by Communism but embraces a traditionally Chinese way of thought to an increasing extent; neither is intuitively familiar to Americans.” Hence, East Asia and China’s role requires a long and judicious perspective.

  • Kevin

    That a left wing opposition group is criticizing the government for not being effective in standing up to China is interesting. it seems to show that in one sense the Chinese are quite ham fisted here. A more supple diplomacy would involve supporting factions in neighboring countries to support China’s ambitions (much as Putin does with FN in France, etc.) instead they are driving the opposition to support a nationalist reaction against China.

    I wonder to what extent this is a legacy of China’s imperial history which, during periods of Chinese unity under powerful dynasties, often emphasized the role of imperial will and legitimacy, as well as the proper suzerian-vassal relationship between China and its neighbors, in foreign affairs due to its overwhelming size. A newly unified and powerful China under the PRC might feel the need to behave this way in order to reinforce its claim to be a great Chinese regime .in the eyes of its citizens. (After all, does the CCP really have the Mandate of Heaven if the Koreans, Japanese and Vietnamese don’t pay it the proper respect?) This imperial tradition and mindset of course will push its neighbors to band together against it…

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2016 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service