mead cohen berger shevtsova garfinkle michta grygiel blankenhorn
That'll Teach Them
Parents Stage Common Core Sit-Out

This week several states test whether their students are meeting common core standards—but some students are sitting out in protest, the New York Times reports. Students who choose to sit out won’t see serious punishments, but if enough don’t take the test, the school as a whole could face consequences, like lost funds or amped up monitoring. It’s not clear exactly how many people will be in on this ‘sit-out,’ but what’s particularly notable is the assortment of coalitions sympathetic to their cause:

“There are forces united against it on the left side of the aisle and the right of the aisle,” said James Crisfield, a former superintendent of the school district in Millburn, N.J. “We’re also talking about things that are happening to one’s child. You mix that all up into a caldron and it does create some really high levels of interest, high levels of passion — and, shall we say, enthusiasm.”

The left dislikes it because the tests provide fodder for evaluating teachers and the right dislikes it because they are suspicious of uniform federal standards foisted on different states. That latter objection seems right to us—evaluation is good, but should be locally generated—but the more interesting point the article raises is how bipartisan this intense grassroots opposition is. In a polarized country, perhaps common core has achieved the miraculous feat of uniting unions and parents afraid of a “federal takeover”of education. That suggests in turn just how difficult it has become to solve problems on the federal level. As we remarked on another occasion, “America is too big and its citizens are too diverse for one-size-fits-all solutions to some of our culture war issues.” If the common core movement is any guide, that may be true for education policy, as well.

Features Icon
show comments
  • Larry Seltzer

    There’s some of this in my town (Maplewood NJ, adjacent to Millburn). My sense of it is that most of the concern by the parents is that the tests appear at this point to be really hard, and they’re afraid little Johnny’s self-esteem will be bruised. It’s true that the tests are challenging.

  • johngbarker

    If Common Core is like most federal programs, it is an income transfer scam masquerading as a education reform. I am sure educational publishers will make a fortune without generating any important learning gains. Recent assessments by Brookings of Common Core suggests this is the case.

    • f1b0nacc1

      I see a lot of this. The textbook publishers are spending a LOT of money lobbying for this, both officially and unofficially

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2016 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service