mead cohen berger shevtsova garfinkle michta grygiel blankenhorn
Blue Civil War
Philly School Reformers to Teacher Union: The War Is On

The reform commission tasked with finding funds for Philadelphia’s cash-strapped school system made an audacious move yesterday: It canceled the teachers’ union contract and ruled that teachers must make contributions to their own health insurance. (h/t  Public Sector Inc.) The Wall Street Journal reports:

“We can’t say to students, ‘We would like to give you millions of dollars to improve schools, but the PFT won’t let its members pay for some of its health insurance,’” School Reform Commission Chairman Bill Green said, referring to the Philadelphia Federation of Teachers.

Governments nationwide have been seeking to rein in costs of health care and other benefits, but there appears to be little precedent for the five-member commission’s unanimous move, education experts said. […]

It isn’t clear if the commission even has the legal authority to void the contract under the state’s school takeover law. Its leaders quickly filed a lawsuit, joined by the state Department of Education, asking a judge to rule they have such power.

The move, which comes after what was said to be a stalemated disagreement with the union, would save the school district millions of dollars:

Mr. Green said Monday’s move, coming after what he called 21 months of fruitless talks with the union, would save the district $54 million this year. He said $30 million of that would be quickly pumped into schools beset by large class sizes, reductions in arts and Advanced Placement classes, and cuts to guidance counselors.

Mr. Green said requiring teachers to pay toward health insurance puts them in the same position as other district employees and most American workers. Philadelphia’s school system, whose 135,000 students make it one of the largest in the U.S., has been overseen by the commission since a 2001 state takeover that was spurred in part by major financial problems and disappointing test scores.

The new contributions work out to between $27 and $71 dollars per month for individual teachers, or $77 to $200 for families.

Union leaders are vowing to fight the decision. It could have national repercussions, according to one expert quoted by

David Gregory, a law professor at St. John’s University in New York, who directs the Center for Employment and Labor Law there, called the SRC’s action “stark and startling,” and said it took a page from Detroit’s cancelling police officers’ and firefighters’ contracts.

Still, Gregory said, “There’s no doubt we’re in uncharted waters in Philadelphia.”

He said the matter “has all the hallmarks to go to the state’s highest court, or potentially, if it gets enough legal traction, to get vaulted into the federal courts and ultimately to the U.S. Supreme Court.”

The Philadelphia commission’s move is particularly dramatic, but as health care costs continue to rise and blue model municipalities sink deeper into debt, we may see similar fights break out elsewhere. Battles over school systems often pit teachers’ unions against the low-income students, a sure-fire quandary for Democrats.

Features Icon
show comments
  • rheddles

    This has been going on all over PA for the last 3 years. Philly is late to the party, probably because their union is even more powerful than those in smaller communities. Reality is a difficult concept for educationists.

  • wigwag

    It;s time for the Philadelphia teachers Union and the Philadelphia school board to wake up and realize that they face a common enemy; the medical cartel which is responsible for driving health care costs through the roof. Instead of fighting each other, they would make much more progress if they worked together to attack that medical cartel.

  • Arch

    The education industry needs to decide whether they exist to benefit students or serve as a welfare agency for otherwise unemployable teachers. The fight is being waged on a broad front ranging from accountability, home schooling, common core, charter schools, lunches children won’t eat to teachers’ benefits. My money is on the children; they are what matters.

    • Kevin

      They decided a long time ago, and it’s not the children.

  • lord acton

    The medical and educational cartels are BOTH doing a great job of impoverishing the whole nation.

  • Kevin

    “Battles over school systems often pit teachers’ unions against the low-income students, a sure-fire quandary for Democrats.”

    Fortunately for them, in this case they will be able to rally together and blame the evil Republicans who run the state gov’t. Philly has a long way further down to go before they will start facing reality and actually working to improve the city.

  • Josephbleau

    I want teaching to be separated from the teachers cartel. Many PhD and Masters folks whom are 65 years old would love to teach in internet or cc. let the lisencure fall!

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2016 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service