mead cohen berger shevtsova garfinkle michta grygiel blankenhorn
Lessons From Obamacare History


Obamacare is more unpopular than ever, and the law’s future has become increasingly uncertain. In the midst of the ongoing controversy, Politico has a fascinating retrospective on the ACA, from its almost accidental origins to its role in defining  Obama’s presidency:

Soon-to-be-candidate Obama, then an Illinois senator, was thinking about turning down an invitation to speak at a big health care conference sponsored by the progressive group Families USA, when two aides, Robert Gibbs and Jon Favreau, hit on an idea that would make him appear more prepared and committed than he actually was at the moment.

Why not just announce his intention to pass universal health care by the end of his first term?

Thus was born Obamacare, a check-the-box, news-cycle expedient that would ultimately define a president.

“We needed something to say,” recalled one of the advisers involved in the discussion. “I can’t tell you how little thought was given to that thought other than it sounded good. So they just kind of hatched it on their own. It just happened. It wasn’t like a deep strategic conversation.”

Obama was at first reluctant to embrace the issue, but gradually became convinced that health care reform would be his main legacy. The result of this evolution is now familiar. Rather than prioritize the Administration’s response to the recession, as most Americans were demanding, Obama pushed his health plan, ignoring the kind of resistance that led to Scott Brown’s election and jamming the bill through Congress.

The Politico piece reads almost like an obit for the law, which seems premature. But it’s undeniable that the ACA as it currently exists is much different and much weaker than what Obama set out to achieve. This weakness stems from the political strategy Obama chose. A slower and more comprehensive public discussion process, combined with greater effort to find common ground with the GOP, wouldn’t have eliminated opposition; but it might have produced a bill that didn’t have to be delayed, modified, and restricted in the way the ACA has.

Rising health care costs are still a problem waiting for solutions. Center-right wonks should learn from the ACA saga that coming up with a reform plan is the easiest part of the process. Achieving the right political strategy to get it signed into law and implemented is where the true challenge lies.

Features Icon
show comments
  • seattleoutcast

    I think right-wing wonks learned their lesson in trying to privatize a portion of social security.

  • crabtown

    A lousy 2%.

  • Corlyss

    More evidence of the “ad-hockiness” of this administration of amateurs.

  • Boritz

    *** coming up with a reform plan is the easiest part of the process***
    Especially when you outsource it to a one party congress. i’m assuming that in this context ‘reform plan’ is to plan what ‘reform school’ is to school: A place where you never want to go.

  • bpuharic

    Obamacare is so unpopular that the GOP, which ran 2 presidential elections based on their opposition to it

    lost both times.

    Wonder what would happen if people supported the law?

  • bpuharic

    WRM and the right completely blew it with their hysteria over Obamacare’s costs. Turns out CBO overestimated in 94% of cases the cost of premiums. Most are going to be quite moderate and lower than expected

    And I’m sure the sound we’ll hear from WRM and all the rest of they pollyannas is


  • Opinionated_Vogon

    Obama did nothing to address the real issue with health care costs because that was not his goal. His goal was redistribution; from a perverted concept of social justice. He doesn’t care about the sausage or how its made. He only cares about advancing leftism regardless of the costs.

    And we knew this up front when he lied to Joe the plumber telling him its good for everybody when you spread the wealth around. 5 years on reality disproves that lie. Redistribution is only good for the recipients of the redistribution and not its donors.

    I made a parody video illustrating the lies of Obamacare and its effects.

    Please check it out.



© The American Interest LLC 2005-2016 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service