mead cohen berger shevtsova garfinkle michta grygiel blankenhorn
Tinseltown Meets China

Hollywood and China just can’t seem to get along. Just three years after famed director Steven Spielberg spurned the Beijing Olympics over concerns about Darfur, Christian Bale has gotten into a spat of his own with Chinese officials. The New York Times reports:

The actor Christian Bale was assaulted by government-backed guards on Thursday when he tried to visit a blind lawyer who has been illegally confined to his home in eastern Shandong Province. […]

The encounter, captured by a CNN camera crew who accompanied him on the eight-hour drive from Beijing to Dongshigu village, promises to become a public relations debacle for China, which has been eagerly promoting Mr. Bale’s latest movie, “The Flowers of War,” which premiered last Sunday at the one of the capital’s most important government buildings. […]

The footage of Mr. Bale’s attempted visit is dramatic. In it, he is seen pleading with the men who guard Dongshigu’s entry points and then retreating as they push and punch him. “Why can I not visit this free man?” he asks repeatedly. The men, dressed in thick green winter coats respond with shouts of “Go away.” Even after they have retreated into their car, the group, which included a translator, was chased for 40 minutes by men in a gray van.

This is hardly China’s best week, but we should not overestimate the effects of the Bale incident on Chinese politics. Chinese nationalists (which is most Chinese) generally dislike western celebrities ‘meddling’ as they see it in China’s affairs.  Hollywood loves the Dalia Lama, and many Chinese consider him a dangerous and wily enemy.  If anything, too much attention from glamorous western celebrities can discredit local figures.  Mr. Bale’s profile is higher than usual thanks to his recent role in the most expensive movie in China’s history (Flowers of War) which China hopes might land it an Oscar, but at the end of the day foreign celebrities will not change China.

Features Icon
show comments
  • Luke Lea

    China is a near-totalitarian society, lest we forget. Or would Professor Mead care to disagree?

  • Jacksonian Libertarian

    Who cares what the Chinese say, everyone will have to admit that the Chinese are so afraid of a little blind guy that they have considerable manpower tasked to hold him in extra legal house arrest, and are willing to make a scene to prevent visitors, rather than just throw the guy in prison. Wow, are they crazy. I would think that even Nationalist Chinese will recognize the persecution for what it is, and worry that the same thing can be done to them, they after all aren’t protected American Actors.

  • Keith McLennan

    The Dalai Lama, not the Dalia Lama. Dalia is a Arab woman’s name.

  • Kris

    “Christian Bale has gotten into a spat of his own with Chinese officials”

    Doesn’t mean much in itself: Bale could easily get in a spat with Mother Teresa. 🙂 But yes, pretty bad PR for China.

    Keith@3: Semitic would be more accurate.

  • william

    “but we should not overestimate the effects of the Bale incident on Chinese politics.”

    I’d be happy to see Tom Friedman recognize that China is not perfect, along with the other liberal fascists.

    Freedom is the alternative to slavery.

    But Power over others is soooooooo attractive!

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2016 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service