mead cohen berger shevtsova garfinkle michta grygiel blankenhorn
Grey Lady Fumbles in Africa

Only six years after the resolution of its civil war, Burundi is again on edge. A bar shooting this week resulted in the deaths of at least 36 Burundians, and the violence has roots in the ongoing conflict between the governing party and the opposition. The New York Times reports:

Burundian officials immediately accused an armed opposition political party that had recently fled into the thick forests of neighboring Democratic Republic of Congo, and many Burundians fear that their country could be sliding back toward war. […]

According to witnesses, around 9 p.m. on Sunday, 10 gunmen descended on the Chez Les Amis bar in Gatumba, a small town near the Congo border. An African diplomat in Nairobi said that the bar was owned by a supporter of the Burundian government and that it was a well-known watering hole for fans of the governing party.

Although it provides some basic details, the Times article completely neglects to mention one of the most important aspects of this heinous act: the role of ethnicity. Burundi has long been traumatized by the conflict between Hutu and Tutsi, which have been one of the main drivers of the nation’s politics — and of course is also a factor in violence throughout the region. Both Reuters and RNW suggest the violence is a result of discord between the Hutu-dominated opposition and the Tutsi-led ruling party, but the Grey Lady refuses to sully the pages of her Burundi coverage with tribal names.

This is exactly the type of reporting we don’t need. Africa already gets short shrift in the news media — reporting that willfully obscures key elements of the region’s politics makes things worse. The casual reader of the Times story would see only a tale of senseless violence and come away even more baffled by African politics than he or she already was.

Features Icon
show comments
  • Luke Lea

    Joel Kotkin got it right: tribes and tribalism are too big to ignore, and not just in Africa. Hbd* chick extends the argument to include kinship in general — she’s a great source of mind-changing information on the importance of the varying degrees of consanguinity in all societies including our own.

    In fact differences in outbreeding coefficients is one of the big things that distinguish European societies and America (and that helps explain where we lie in relation to Europe on the libertarian-welfare state axis).

    Brush up on your biology everybody. Human biodiversity is not just — or even mostly — about race. The interactions between genes and culture are fundamental, and not just for abstract understanding but for realistic policy planning.

  • Anthony

    WRM, how much has post World War II Territorial Integrity decisions for much of colonial Africa influenced ongoing civil chaos?

  • Corlyss

    Didn’t the Grey Lady decide decades ago that the only ethnicity that mattered enough to raise was white, so they could simultaneously dismiss it as atavistic bloodthirstiness characteristic of the race?

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2016 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service