mead cohen berger shevtsova garfinkle michta grygiel blankenhorn
Blue Model Corruption
Teacher of the Year, the Illinois Way

In the midst of Illinois’s worsening pension woes, here’s one egregiously odious example of abuse: a retired union lobbyist spent one day as a substitute teacher, and is now receiving a pension for it (at $31,485 per year) thanks to pals in the state’s General Assembly. The Chicago Tribune outed this arrangement back in 2011, whereupon the state reduced his benefits, but—get this—the man is now suing on the premise that the reduction was unconstitutional under state law, and if he wins, he’ll see his benefits increased. That’s on top of the other state pension he has from a job as a legislative aide.

In fact, as a Tribune editorial points out, David Piccioli is quite the “poster boy” for Illinois’s public unions:

[Piccioli is taking] the same position the state’s public employee unions have taken before the Illinois Supreme Court as they try to block a 2013 pension reform law. The constitution says retiree benefits can’t be “diminished or impaired,” the unions argue, so find another solution to your $111 billion unfunded obligation. Looking at you, Illinois taxpayers. […]

Piccioli’s lawsuit certainly doesn’t help the unions’ case as they dig in their heels against pension reforms. Illinois doesn’t have enough money to meet its obligations to bona fide retirees. One of every four dollars goes to pensions.

Union employees say they’ve made the contributions they agreed on, and they want the benefits they were promised. This isn’t a crisis of their making, they say.

Never mind that unions signed off on years of pension holidays in return for the generous benefits the state now can’t afford.

This case is a window into the system of closed governance and public union lobbying. It’s not just Illinois—any system this badly run and this susceptible to insider pressure for special deals is going to be rife with abuses. It is the blue model in a nutshell: public unions spend big to elect politicians, who remain in their pocket and pay them back in kind. Responsibility to the taxpayer? Forget it.

Features Icon
show comments
  • Boritz

    Let me be the first to deny that this is in any way an indictment of the blue model. Just don’t see that. This is more likely an issue with people named David whose last name sounds a little like the name of s high pitched orchestral instrument. Nothing to see here.

  • Josephbleau

    Madigan and his gang of thieves have stolen more than Al Capone yet they do it in the light of day while passing laws that make their criminality psudo-legal. I think that there are fair services acts that make it a crime to take a pension for one day of work, if not then shame alone should prevent a normal person from this ugly display of greed, St. Daley got a similar pension. Have you no shame, at long last, have you no shame.

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2016 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service