walter russell mead peter berger lilia shevtsova adam garfinkle andrew a. michta
Feed
Features
Reviews
Podcast
peace and diplomacy?
You Won't Believe What the Iranian Foreign Minister Said After He Honored a Notorious Terrorist

Iranian Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif had some contradictory announcements to make when he visited Lebanon this week. First, Zarif paid his respects and laid a wreath at the tomb of his fallen comrade Imad Mughniyeh in Beirut. Mughniyeh was a senior Hezbollah commander who was killed in 2008 by a car bomb of unknown origin. He is deemed responsible for orchestrating the 1983 bombings of the U.S. Embassy and Marine barracks in Lebanon that killed hundreds of Americans. Zarif then met with Hassan Nasrallah, the chief of Hezbollah, and several Lebanese government officials before giving a press conference. At the press conference, he announced Iran’s commitment to “combatting terrorism,” which is a “dangerous phenomenon” that requires “international cooperation.”

It might seem strange for the Iranian Foreign Minister to first pay his respects to a deceased mass murderer and terrorist, then hold a meeting with the head of one of the most powerful terrorist organizations in the world, then claim to be committed to eradicating terrorism across the Middle East. But there’s a method to his madness: Iran is using the discussions on its nuclear program to project an image of moderation even as it dramatically steps up its campaign to establish itself as the leading power in the Middle East.

The strategy is working, in part because Washington is afraid to call Tehran on it. Desperate for a nuclear deal (reflecting both President Obama’s deep convictions about the importance of non-proliferation and the administration’s headlong rush for the exit from a Middle East it has signally failed to stabilize), Washington appears ready to swallow any toads Iran wants to jam down its throat.

While officials from the P5+1 countries congratulate each other on an “interim agreement” and a “temporary freeze” on Iran’s nuclear enrichment program, the Iranian negotiating team claims that there is a secret side deal with details on Iran’s right to continue nuclear development over the next few months. While President Obama fights to prevent new Iran sanctions, saying they would be a “march toward war,” Iran is stepping up its military and economic support for Hezbollah, the Assad regime in Damascus, and Shiite militia groups in Iraq, Syria, Yemen, and Bahrain. While Washington tries to spin the interim agreement with Iran as a step forward for “peace and diplomacy,” Iran’s Foreign Minister pays his respects to notorious mass murderer (of Americans!), and Iran’s “moderate” new President Hassan Rouhani went on Twitter to boast that “world powers surrendered to the Iranian nation’s will.”

Some have claimed that these actions by Iranian officials signal “insincerity,” but we don’t see anything insincere here. Iran sincerely wants to establish an Iran-dominated Shia Crescent from Basra and Baghdad in Iraq across Syria and into Lebanon, and it sincerely believes that the Obama Administration is weak, vacillating, and desperate enough for the facade of a nuclear agreement to let that happen.  Iran sincerely believes that the Sunni world has never been in such disarray or so weak; given all this, a sketchy nuclear deal with the United States that would cement Iran in place as the region’s dominant power looks genuinely attractive to the mullahs in Tehran. Why wouldn’t it?

As long as Iran thinks it can have it all, we won’t be testing whether it is really prepared to settle for a fair compromise in the Middle East. As long as this administration keeps the nuclear talks rolling and enforces a rigid separation between Iran’s activities beyond the talks and progress on sanctions, we won’t know Iran’s real bottom line.

Franklin Roosevelt once said that you can’t turn a tiger into a kitten by stroking it. President Obama appears to disagree. Time will tell who was right.

Features Icon
Features
show comments
  • Brian Stahl

    In what way do you think that they have been stepping up their attempts to establish themselves in the Middle East? I don’t see anything concrete in this piece. Also, I wouldn’t read too much into a self-aggrandizing tweet by Rouhani: world leaders say things like this all the time.

    • Kavanna

      That’s why it’s called TWITter. The root of Twitter is, not “wit,” but “twit.”

  • gabrielsyme

    One thing is clear, and one thing is unclear in relation to Iran. What is clear is their intent to expand their efforts to support Shia power in the Middle East. What we don’t know is if there’s a constituency lead by Zarif and Rouhani that genuinely wants to trade access to nuclear weapons for economic considerations and perhaps a freer hand in Syria, Iraq and so forth. Zarif and Rouhani’s statements are probably more consistent with individuals trying to maintain support in a difficult political situation than two guys involved in a long play on the US & the West.

    I think the trade of removing sanctions for nuclear security is worth making, and I think that’s a fair possibility. It’s still worth pursuing.

  • Corlyss

    Why wouldn’t savvy readers believe it? Iran has no fear, of the US or of Israel. They know Obama’s a weak woman when it comes to enforcement of anything except racial preferences and wars on Republicans.

  • Kavanna

    And for my next joke, you’ll never believe it! It didn’t happen, and they’re here to finish the job.

    Something witty told by eastern European Jews about German Jews in the 1930s:

    A German Jewish man is walking down the street in Berlin circa 1935. A large limo pulls up and out come Goering and his entourage. He points to the man and then to a nearby pile of doggy-do and shouts to the man that he must kneel and eat it. Which he does.

    Later, the man arrives at home, where his wife is waiting for him. As he enters, he exclaims, “Honey, I’m home — you’ll never guess who I had lunch with today!”

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2014 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service