mead cohen berger shevtsova garfinkle michta grygiel blankenhorn
Another Fraud Within a Fraud


Executives at the Indiana-based biofuels producer E-Biofuels have enjoyed lavish lifestyles over the past five years, driving Ferraris, buying Picassos and wearing diamonds. These luxuries weren’t the result of hard work and honest profits, but fraud. Now investors and taxpayers alike are out more than $100 million in what federal prosecutors are calling the largest tax and securities fraud case in the state’s history. The Indianapolis Star reports:

Court documents say E-Biofuels would buy low-grade fuel from elsewhere, ship it to its Middletown plant, switch the labels, mark up the prices and sell the product as premium fuel.

E-Biofuels executives and their associates, prosecutors say, then would cash in on tens of millions of dollars in federal tax incentives geared toward producers of premium biofuel….

Evans said this fraud case is similar to cases in Texas and Maryland, where two other biofuel company executives also fraudulently collected on tax incentives. The CEO of Lubbock, Texas-based Absolute Fuels was sentenced to 15 years in federal prison this April, while the head of Maryland-based Clean Green Fuel was sentenced to more than 12 years in February.

Of course, this messy situation probably wouldn’t have developed had the US not decided in 2007 to mandate increasingly high biofuel production quotas. The fraud committed by the executives at E-Biofuels was obviously criminal, but the more serious fraud undergirding this whole mess is America’s misguided biofuels policy, which ends up raising food prices (starving the world’s poor) and forcing refiners to snatch up increasingly expensive ethanol credits—and it isn’t even green. It’s a mess of perverse incentives, and E-Biofuels isn’t the first to take advantage.

[Withered corn crop image courtesy of Shutterstock]

Features Icon
show comments
  • Jacksonian_Libertarian

    Government meddling in the free market system, never turns out well. They are fundamentally incapable of picking winners because their motivation isn’t to make a profit, but political and rent seeking (corruption).

    • bpuharic

      When I was a kid I believed in monsters under the bed. Right wingers still believe in myths like the ‘free market’. A reflection of fundamentalism in religion, I guess. Funny how their view of economics parallels their view of religion

      The fact is there is no such thing as a ‘free market’. It’s a theoretical construct that exists only in the mind like a perfect gas. The most unrestricted market in US history was in the 19th century, with little govt interference. It was an age, as Adam Smith predicted, of businessmen conspiring against the public iinterest

      Funny how many right wingers have read Ayn Rand and other myths. Few have read Adam Smith and the need for a regulated market.

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2016 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service