mead cohen berger shevtsova garfinkle michta grygiel blankenhorn
Blue States Attack Secular Monks In Fiscal Crunch

In the old days when times got tough, cash hungry rulers went for the monks.  Henry VIII closed the monasteries and sold off the property to his followers.  The French Revolution did the same.

These days, the church doesn’t have the dough — and if it did, class action lawyers for sex abuse victims get there first.  So cash-strapped states have to look to our secular monasteries: tax-exempt nonprofits.  From a piece by Stephanie Strom in the New York Times:

A growing number of nonprofit groups in California are being denied exemption from property taxes because the state’s chief tax collector and assessors contend they do not do enough to benefit state residents, according to lawyers representing the groups.

The coffers are empty, and they have to be filled — even if that means slapping taxes on charitable groups sending famine relief overseas. Other states follow where California leads:

State and local governments have been taking a hard look at nonprofits and the various tax exemptions they receive for the last couple of years, as tax revenues have fallen and the demand for public services has risen.

Last year, Hawaii tried — and failed — to impose a 1 percent tax on nonprofit groups. Boston has asked nonprofits to pay the city what is essentially a discounted property tax, and Chicago plans to ask nonprofits to start paying water and sewer fees.

Because the revenue model is broken — the bureaucratic-administrative state cannot provide the services progressive ideology demands at affordable costs — the demands of the state for more and more revenue turn bureaucrats and government employees against their ideological allies in the “progressive” foundations and non-profits.

The rift between upper middle class gentry liberals and government workers is growing, and it has the potential to tear the Democratic Party apart.

Features Icon
show comments
  • Kenny

    ” … and it has the potential to tear the Democratic Party apart.”

    The sooner the better.

    And if you think that’s bad, just wait until the blacks finally realize how bad the coalition between the Democratic Party and the near lilly white teachers unions have been for their minority kids.

  • Bob

    We saw a hint of this coming when President Obama floated the idea of taking away the full exemption of donations to non-profits. It was shot down quickly, but the tension was apparent, and it was a rather shocking signal as to where Mr. Obama stood. The President believed that the government’s claim on that money was more important than whatever the non-profits were going to do with it.

  • Christopher

    Eliminating the tax exempt status is a great idea to solve a lot of the financial issues facing communities. The best place to start would be imposing taxes on churches at the same level that other businesses are charged. Please try and explain how a mega-church is not a business.

    Sorry if my financial conservatism does not match with everyones else’s christian idealism.

  • Kris

    In the words of one of last century’s leading Europeans: “Everything for the state, nothing outside of the state”.

  • Kris

    Or to expand on the words of one who lived in a backward time and a strange land: “Render therefore unto Caesar the things which are Caesar’s”; just remember that the Dominion of Caesar is all-encompassing.

© The American Interest LLC 2005-2016 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service