From the November - December 2008 issue: Russia and the European Order Sovereign Democracy Explained When the Cold War ended in Soviet collapse, the Western commentariat commenced an orgy of self-regarding futurism. The unacknowledged purpose of these paroxysms was to “fit” Russia into a well-ordered future so that the exertions of the Cold War could be said to have been truly worth the effort. Americans tended to see Russia transiting from despotism and imperialism into democracy and international cooperation as modulated through institutions largely fashioned by itself and its allies: NATO, the OSCE, the WTO, the IMF and, for some, the United Nations, which would at last be able to function as the agency of collective security its founders intended. West Europeans, soon joined by East and Central European elites, tended to see a new Russia rising under the aegis of a postmodern Europe. Even if Russia did not join this Europe soon, the European Union’s postmodern, soft-power-only politics would establish the basic templates of exchange in Eurasian space from which Russia would benefit and learn.

In short, Americans and Europeans projected their own overlapping if still distinct understandings and hopes onto Russia, persuading themselves that there was something universal and everything benign about so doing. Even when they did things that irritated the Russians, like expanding NATO into the territory of the former Soviet Union, most persuaded themselves that the Russians would in time come to understand the good reasons for such policies. It was as though Russia were a train on a track that could only go forward or backward. It seems rarely to have occurred to Western politicians and intellectuals that the losers of the Cold War would be doing some projecting of their own, based on their own history and experience, their own frustrations and hopes. When Russia eventually confounded rather than conformed to Western expectations, it began to dawn on some that Russia was not in transit to any Western-designated destination, but was instead headed somewhere else in a vehicle of its own choosing.

...
Want to read more?

The full text of the article is for subscribers only. To continue reading it, please log in below:

Login:
Password:
 
Not a subscriber? Subscribe today for only $19!
Ivan Krastev is chairman of the Centre for Liberal Strategies in Sofia, Bulgaria, and a founding member of the European Council on Foreign Relations. See also: A Retired Power by Ivan Krastev
Share this Article: