mead cohen berger shevtsova garfinkle michta grygiel blankenhorn
Game of Thrones
Japan's Pacifists Fight Back

Yesterday in Tokyo, 3,000 people protested against Prime Minister Shinzo Abe’s plans to remilitarize the country. Abe’s right-wing government is moving to change the constitution in order to do away with pacifism and give a more active role to the military. But not everyone in Japan wants to see rearmament.

For some time now, Abe has been targeting Article 9 of Japan’s constitution, which contains the famous line, “The Japanese people forever renounce war as a sovereign right of the nation and the threat or use of force as means of settling international disputes.” As Japan’s relations with China and North Korea grow more tense, Abe’s administration has argued that Japan needs to “reinterpret” this clause to permit “collective defense,” allowing Japan, for example, to send military aid to an embattled ally. The clause has been interpreted to mean that Japan can’t respond militarily unless it is directly attacked.

A new poll by the Asahi Shimbun suggests that Abe and the Japanese electorate don’t see eye to eye on this question: 63 percent oppose the concept of collective defense, up from 56 percent last year, while just 29 percent support it. Kenzaburo Oe, a Nobel Prize laureate in literature, told the rally in Tokyo yesterday: “By exercising the collective self-defense, Japan will directly participate in a war…. I’m afraid that Japan’s spirit is approaching the most dangerous stage over the past 100 years.”

The tension between pacifism and remilitarization in Japanese society is becoming more apparent. Japan’s upper house of parliament passed a bill yesterday that will give the government greater control over schools’ selection of textbooks. This is worrisome because  government-supported textbooks whitewash the brutality of Japan’s military occupations during World War II. One schoolteacher told the BBC in an interview, “They are stirring up nationalism, stirring up feelings against China, saying that’s why we need a strong military. They want to use the textbooks to condition our children to the idea of a strong military.”

Features Icon
show comments
  • Breif2

    “63 percent oppose the concept of collective defense”

    Do they wish the US to adopt the same standard?

  • Jim__L

    “I’m afraid that Japan’s spirit is approaching the most dangerous stage over the past 100 years.”

    Let’s see what dates are included in the last 100 years, shall we?
    – 18 September 1931
    – 15 May 1932
    – 7 December 1941
    – 4 June 1942
    – 6 August 1945
    – 9 August 1945

    Most dangerous stage in the last 68 years? Perhaps. But it seems that Japanese pacifists have no more sense than American greens.

    • B-Sabre

      That goes without saying. Most Japanese pacifists like to present the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki as things that just happened out of the blue…”We were just standing here, minding our own business…and this happened! Woe is us!”

      • Jim__L

        Yeah, there is a certain amount of historical denial amongst that kind of activist. (tangent)

        On the other hand, I’ve always seen two kinds of “deniers” of historical atrocities… one kind says the atrocity didn’t happen, but it would have been nice if it did. There’s nothing to be done with these types, except suspect that they’d have second thoughts if it looked as if they might actually catch that car they’re chasing.

        The other kind is the kind that thinks of the atrocity, “That’s such a horrible atrocity, no [person / organization / group of people] I admire could possibly have done such a thing.” This type of person doesn’t worry me nearly so much. They buy into the idea that an atrocity is an atrocity, and it shouldn’t happen. Very likely, if they emulated the [person / organization / group of people] they admired, their emulation would not include those atrocities.

        The second kind can still be very dangerous if the atrocity is ongoing, though… these are the types of “useful idiots” that allowed Marxism to thrive, or allowed the Holocaust to happen.


© The American Interest LLC 2005-2016 About Us Masthead Submissions Advertise Customer Service